It’s that time of year, when everybody’s coming out with their “Best-Of Lists” and we are adding yet another list to the pile. Welcome to The First Annual NOTTIE AWARDS, our version of the numerous Awards shows that get televised across the planet. Our list varies from other awards, in the fact that we cover the entire year of 2014. The NOTTIE AWARDS, breaks down the year starting with the 2013/2014 season’s conclusion, going through the summer shows as the first half of the year. The second half of the year covers the 2014-2015 Television season, making sure that all performances throughout the year, receive the recognition, they deserve.
As you peruse the list, you’ll notice that all categories have four names, except for two categories; Most disappointing series of the second half’s vacant. The other category that breaks the rule’s the Best Supporting Actor, in the second half, there were far too many outstanding performances to limit that category to just four actors. In all categories, the name listed first and in blue, won the category, the runner-up’s listed second and in red, the third and fourth names are just randomly listed.
All choices were made by Jason Jones and I, all decisions by the Judges are final (Although, We’d Love Your Feed-Back.)
And on to the Awards:
Best Actor: James Spader-The Blacklist, Tom Mison-Sleepy Hollow, Lee Pace- Halt and Catch Fire, Sean Bean-Legends
Best Supporting Actor: Peter Capaldi-The Musketeers, Walton Goggins-Justified, Jon Voight-Ray Donovan, Tom Felton-Murder in the First
Best Actress: Mackenzie Davis- Halt and Catch Fire, Joelle Carter-Justified, Kerry Bishe- Halt and Catch Fire, Kathleen Robertson-Murder in the First
Best Supporting Actress: Amy Acker-Person of Interest, Tamla Kari-The Musketeers, Sarah Shahi-Person of Interest, Marissa Neitling-The Last Ship
Most Disappointing Show: The Leftovers, The Black Box, Resurrection, Power
Best New Show: The Blacklist, Legends, Halt and Catch Fire, Murder in the First
Most Underrated Show: Justified, Supernatural, The Musketeers, Halt and Catch Fire
Best Show: The Blacklist, Person of Interest, Legends, Justified
Best Actor: Jeff Daniels-The Newsroom, Ioan Gruffold-Forever, Elyes Gabel-Scorpion, Matt Ryan-Constantine
Best Supporting Actor: Sam Waterston- The Newsroom, John Noble- Sleepy Hollow, Judd Hirsch-Forever, Misha Collins-Supernatural, Jesse L Martin-The Flash, Mark Sheppard-Supernatural, Michael James Shaw-Constantine, Robert Patrick-Scorpion, Mandy Patinkin-Homeland, Robin Lord Taylor-Gotham, Sean-Pertwee-Gotham, Donal Logue-Gotham, Rupert Friend-Homeland
Best Actress: Claire Danes-Homeland, Anna Gunn-Gracepoint, Emily Mortimer-The Newsroom, Alana De La Garza-Forever
Best Supporting Actress Olivia Munn-The Newsroom, Jacki Weaver-Gracepoint, Elizabeth Henstridge-Agents of SHIELD, Chloe Bennett-Agents of SHIELD
Most Disappointing Show: None Applicable
Best New Show: Forever, Scorpion, Constantine, Gotham
Most Underrated Show: Constantine, Forever, Scorpion, Sleepy Hollow
Best Show: The Newsroom, Homeland, Person of Interest, Forever
Here we find ourselves on the doorsteps of a series finale we all hoped we could delay. The Newsroom has been every bit the Sorkin gem we’d hoped it would be. Even at its most unimpressive moment, The Newsroom still stands head and shoulders above 90% of what television has had to offer during it’s run. Jeff Daniels has been amazing. Sam Waterston has been career defining good. Each and every character has found a way to pull us in.
Thinking back to the pilot episode, there was about a 50/50 split. There were characters I liked immediately and ones that took time to grow on me. Reese Lansing, Don Keefer, and even Maggie Jordan. As we look back before the series finale, even the people I did not care for, have found a way into the proverbial heart. An ability that very few writers have, Aaron Sorkin accomplishes with resounding results.
Tonight is the last episode of the journey in the ‘mission to civilize’. The swan song for raising the collective expectation for what delivering the news should mean. The swan song for that dying breed of the honorable newsman. One last hurrah for us the viewer to experience something fictional, seldom found in day-to-day non-fiction.
Mack: Reclaiming journalism as an honorable profession. A nightly newscast that informs a debate worthy of a great nation. Civility, respect, and a return to what’s important; the death of bitchiness; the death of gossip and voyeurism; speaking truth to stupid. No demographic sweet spot; a place where we all come together.
I don’t mean to belabor the point here. The Newsroom took us on a journey of what could and quite frankly, should be the way things are done. We live in a place where ratings and appealing to the lowest common denominator is a blueprint for success. Whether it’s news or reality television, we are satisfied with the sound bite or deplorable. Not because it’s accurate or important. Because the requisite amount of people would tune in to watch this unimportant thing. And that number of viewers sells enough soda or car insurance or toys. The Newsroom, beyond the show, was a metaphor for where we are versus where we came from. At least within the construct of television news.
As recently as today, I saw on social media someone posted a link to the video of Will McAvoy’s first speech about “Why is America the Best Country in the World”. This person had no idea that this was from a television show currently running. And that becomes the bigger issue at hand. This is a remarkable show created by a remarkable writer. And that would be enough. This show like a few Sorkin shows before it will prove to measure beyond the scope of entertainment. This show vividly shows us a great many things about ourselves, good, bad or otherwise.
Everything Aaron Sorkin does has tremendous merit. Every mainstream project he’s ever completed increases in value. Like a great artist, his work is normally not truly appreciated until it is too late. I could have easily watched The Newsroom into a 6th season before even considering when it should end. So today is a bittersweet day for me and I imagine anyone who is a fan of The Newsroom or Aaron Sorkin. At the conclusion of tonight’s episode some will reflect and move on to whatever is next on their DVRs. The rest of us will wallow in re-runs of The West Wing, Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, Sports Night, A Few Good Men, American President or whatever Aaron Sorkin works they may have at their disposal. Without any further delay, let us look forward and see exactly how this story ends.
We begin the series finale exactly where we should. At Charlie Skinner’s funeral. Everyone is present. All those we expect and some we might not have. Everyone except Mackenzie, because she’s outside having a very cryptic phone conversation. She quietly sneaks back into the funeral service. She attempts to whisper something to Will, who if famous masculine fashion misses it the first time. Mack tries again and only two phrases (under the circumstances) are required. “My Doctor” and “blood test”. A natural and convincing smile grows on Will’s face.
We immediately follow-up that great news with a three-year flashback that starts with Will yelling for ‘Ellen’. Those viewers who go back to the beginning know what this is. This is the Show Runners for The Newsroom taking a moment to show us exactly how detached Will McAvoy was. Not knowing Maggie’s name. Not knowing what Neal even does. Strong arming his executive producer. And Charlie Skinner watching the broadcast moments before the decision not to right the ship, but to rebuild the ship.
During this flashback we get something I thought we’d never see again as of last week. Charlie Skinner in a benevolent manner giving it Will regardless of how Will feels about that. He beats around the bush asking if Will ever plans on kids. Will gives some reply about being afraid to pass down some of his father’s demons and questioning if it’s worth it in the long run. Charlie then redirects the conversation back to the current state of the show. He is going news segment by news segment, pointing out deficiencies and missed opportunities on Will’s part. Trying to get passed the ratings and to begin talking about content. Charlie walks us all the way up the line in the sand. He even asks bluntly, “what are we doing?” Then just before concluding the flashback, Charlie leans back in his seat and says, “Being a father…it lives up to the hype.” The flashback washes away to reveal a truly joyous Will McAvoy smile.
When the funeral service concludes, Will and Mack struggle to get passed the lines and into open space. Will then, in first time Dad form, pulls Mack aside to ask 20 questions. We, in this moment, run down a relative checklist. Then in typical Will fashion he declares that the next 7 months will go smoothly because he is in charge of morale.
Will: Do we know if it’s a boy or a girl?
Mack: Yes. It will likely be one of those two.
Leona Lansing wants Mack to ride with her to the cemetery. She then ‘invites’ Pruitt to join them. Pruitt is clearly still ticked about the interview prior to Charlie’s heart attack. In a different limo, Maggie hold Jim’s hand in silence. Jim breaks out the ‘nice service’ line before Maggie interrupts him. Maggie was recommended for a promotion to ‘Field Producer, Washington DC’. An interview she would not likely be in line for, had Jim not recommended her.
In the Lansing limo, Leona outlines Pruitt’s problem. Pruitt owns a company that is not worth explaining. Multiple news stories have surfaced with allegations that Pruitt pays the woman of this company less. Less even that the national average. This then sparks an impromptu debate over the subject of unfair pay, conceptually. Mack gives her piece even though she doesn’t know why she was invited. Leona then informs Pruitt that today, she will help him out.
In yet another limo we find Will, Don and Sloan. Don and Sloan are almost having a non-verbal, eyes are screaming at each other conversation. Then Sloan speaks up. They think it’s important that Will know exactly what happened leading up to Charlie’s heart attack. It sounds exactly like you’d think it would. Sloan speaking a mile a minute and Will just taking it in. Then there will be a portion of the story that Don tells, which should alleviate any fault away from Sloan and onto Don.
New flashback takes us to Charlie and Mackenzie’s first meeting. At 11:30am on a Monday in a dark bowling alley. She is bad at bowling and it is apparent that she has been drinking. The two of them sit down and before you know it, she’s explaining the lack of career options she has. Then Charlie suggests that had she not been drinking and her head was clear, she might ask why Charlie was there (she is aware of who Charlie Skinner is).
Mack: …Hang on…YEAH. That’s for sure what I would have done.
Charlie: I want you to take over News Night.
(Mack stares blankly then leans back in confusion)
The flashback continues with Sloan Sabbath talking to Don and ripping Will’s interview pertaining to a news story that is right in Sloan’s area of expertise. Don let’s her rant and then fires back. Pointing out that she only talks about one subject for one hour. Don and his host are responsible for much more than that. He then goes on to explain how nothing she’s said makes any sense to even an informed person so maybe she should work on her job instead of ripping them for doing theirs. To look in her eyes, that might have been the moment that opened the door for their eventual relationship.
After trying to process what Charlie has just said, Mack begins to break down why it can’t work. She gives up the previous ‘romantic’ relationship. A relationship that has long since ended. She cites reason after reason and each time she does, Charlie agrees with her. Charlie points out that when the two of them worked together, they really put something special together. She keeps resisting based on her relationship with Will, or lack thereof. Charlie is pursuing her because of that very relationship.
Mack: Don’s a smart guy and from what I hear a good EP, what makes you think I have better luck than Don making your car go fast?
Charlie: Because Will doesn’t care about impressing Don.
Mack: You’re not offering me the job in spite of my history with Will, you’re offering it to me because of it.
Charlie: I’m offering it to you because you’re my best hope of turning our flagship news hour into something we can be proud of.
Mack: He hasn’t returned any of my phone calls or emails or letters in…years. I don’t think he’s all that interested in what I think of him.
Charlie: That may be the only thing he’s interested in. (Charlie stands up) An offer’s on the table, Midterms are in six months, and another Presidential campaign in two years. Take the offer and you’ll have a chance to frame the debate. Or pass, but then you never get to complain about the news again.
The very next shot is Mack walking up to will call at a venue to pick up her ticket to the debate at Northwestern. We even find Jenna (the student who Will will eventually rip on stage, and who will eventually work for Will) outside getting her ticket as well. While they wait in line, Mack notices Jenna writing something down. She’s curious so she asks if the lady will ask a question to the panel? This is where Mackenzie gets the question that Will is destined to obliterate and he does so because Mackenzie provides him with the answer while he thinks of a way to sidestep the question.
Back in real-time Pruitt tries to spin to Leona what he and his PR Firm are going to do about his perceived problem with women. Pruitt believes he has all the steps in place to make this go away. Leona leans in and suggests that Pruitt has a PR problem because he has an actual problem.
The part of the story Don was going to tell Will that would take the pressure off of Sloan was the college girl who created the website for those victims of sexual assault on campus. As Don tells it, it was a bad story that Pruitt wanted. Pinning victim vs accused in studio live. It would have been Jerry Springer on network news. Don explains how this was a standoff between Don and Charlie and Charlie lost. Then Will asks if they should go bury Charlie now or if Don and Sloan believe they’ve already done that.
Back in the past Charlie views the Northwestern speech via YouTube like the rest of the planet. Then we find Will (on vacation) explaining to a bartender who honestly could not care any less that the ‘lady in the crowd’ that provided an answer to the question like a producer would, was a hallucination. The bartender’s phone rings. He asks if his patron is Mr. McAvoy and hands him the phone. It’s Leona. Will apologizes for the embarrassment, but Leona doesn’t care.
Leona: You’ve made a career out of being likable.
Will: I’d like to make a career out of doing the news.
(a long pause)
Leona: Who’s stopping you? (she hangs up before he can respond)
Sloan shows up again a Don’s office (still 3 years ago). She is there to adequately explain what she tried and failed to do before. She explains it in a way that most people should understand. Don follows it wonderfully. Right as she begins to bring her explanation to a close, he cuts her off. Admits that he is no longer the EP of News Night. He then goes further by admitting that Will doesn’t like to come off as rude on camera. Finally a step even further, admits that Will blew the interview. That everyone concerned would have been better off if they let Sloan keep the interview. We’ll call this moment #2 that opened the door to their eventual relationship.
Here’s a fun fact, Jim Harper is impressively good at playing the guitar. I did not know that. Mackenzie shows up at Jim’s apartment. He’s recently broken with a long distance girlfriend and he’s been drinking. Mack lays it out rather quickly and he is resistant. Then Mack pulls out the book Charlie sent her as a metaphor of his intentions. The book was Don Quixote, which as we know plays a relevant part in a future episode. So, Charlie really did orchestrate this in the most literal terms.
Will is outside Charlie’s wake talking to three female staffers and one male. He says that it is “suddenly” important that he monitor his health. That’s when he realizes he’s smoking a cigarette and puts it out immediately. Then removes all the others from the pack. The Martin asks why ‘suddenly’? Will deflects. Then Tess figures it out. Then Kendra and so on. Martin still has no clue. Fearing he’s violated some spousal trust, he immediately backpedals and insists they are forget the conversation ever happened.
Maggie is getting mixed signals or misinterpreting signals that aren’t present in regards to Jim recommending her to DC. I was really starting to come around to new and improved Maggie Jordan. If she messes this up, I’m going to be significantly upset with her.
Leona’s angle to help Pruitt continues but with marginal clarity. Pruitt explains what happened with the Bree interview and asks how can he not fire Mack and Sloan. Then Leona transitions back to Charlie. She explains that he wants a news director he will fight with. He also doesn’t want the ACN he thinks he wants. He wants the fight, because the fight means both sides are doing their jobs. It feels like Leona is leaning towards a recommendation for Charlie’s replacement that Pruitt probably won’t like at first glance.
At ACN the ‘digital team’ are working. And by working I mean not working and ripping movies for the fun of it. The one of the ‘digital team’ computers suffers an error. Then another. They frantically scurry to find the problem. One guy suggests they got hacked. Then Bree says, “this wasn’t a hacker, somebody just walked in”.
Neal: I shut it down from my phone.
Bree: Are you Neal?
Bree: Welcome back man…
Neal: The nine most overrated movies of all time?
Bree: We thought it’d be fun.
Neal: For who?
Bree: For movie fans…?
Neal: I see you went all the way back to the Matrix. 1999. All time and 14 years are two completely different units of measurement, but my question is why is overrated more fun than overrated? You embarrass me.
Bree: I what?
Neal: It took me a long time to build ACN Digital. I was laughed at by the people in this newsroom. People I respect did not respect what I did around here, but I built this into a tool. I gathered, expanded upon and disseminated it into information that is useful. I kept telling my colleagues and my bosses that the internet is user sensitive just like most things. And I watched from a thousand miles away while you proved that. You embarrass me.
(Neal turns slightly to the other guy)
Neal: Build a page that says the site is down for repair.
Guy#2: For an hour?
Neal: For a week. We’re going to rebuild the whole thing.
Mackenzie finds Will staring blankly from the middle a young boys room. Then he demands that they finish the renovations on the apartment so they can sell it, buy a house, with a pile of leaves in the front yard and a flat street for riding a bicycle on.
Charlie’s widow escorts Don into Charlie’s home office. Don interrupts. He quickly blurts out that he may have contributed to Charlie’s heart attack. He begins to outline the circumstance, she cuts him off and explains that Charlie didn’t want the story. Charlie was banking on Don fighting him over it. Her words of what Charlie thought of Don are moving. Don’s non-verbal reactions are that of a figurative son unaware of his figurative father’s affection. Which is made more poignant when you remember that Charlie needed to be restrained from Don in the pilot episode. Mrs. Skinner passes Don a large manila envelope. She wanted Don to have Charlie’s yellow bow tie.
Will makes his way to the garage where Beau is strumming a cello. Earlier, Charlie told a story of his grandson Beau and that he was a musical savant. There was a story about a song called ‘How I Got to Memphis’. Memphis being a metaphor for wherever you are. Will starts to play the song and sing the lyrics. Beau joins in with the cello. Jim comes around the corner. He picks up another guitar and begins to play as well. They are joined by spectators, Gary and Tess. And more join them. There is a large crowd that gives a large ovation. When the crowd dissipates, Will looks to Beau. Acknowledges that he knows that Beau would confide in Charlie. Will makes an offer to do the same, if he’d like.
Mackenzie approaches Will and asks if he told anyone. Memo to new mothers who give the news to the new father. You need to specify that we aren’t supposed to say anything. Otherwise we will out of excitement. His scolding is preempted by Pruitt. He would like a word. It is a short conversation and before they depart for the car, Mack asks one last time if Will would like to say anything on Charlie’s behalf. A running line throughout the episode.
Will: Excuse me. Excuse me. Excuse me everybody. I just want to say…I’ve been trying to piece together what happened last Monday night. People keep giving me their accounts, seems everyone feels responsible for Charlie dying and of course ridiculous. It was Sloan. Charlie Skinner was crazy. He identified with Don Quixote. An old man with dementia who thought he could save the world from an epidemic of incivility simply by acting like a nut. His religion was decency. He spent a lifetime fighting its enemies. I wish he could be here. To learn the name of his successor, like I just did. Our new boss. The new President of ACN is Mackenzie McHale. (Long pause) So this fight is just getting started. Because he taught us to be crazy too. You were a man Charlie. A great big man.
Back at the studio, Mack offers the EP job to Jim. He hesitates as he believes it should go to Don. Don turned it down in favor of building something at ten o’clock. Jim accepts. Jim immediately finds Maggie and tells her to cancel the interview in DC. As Executive Producer of News Night, he is promoting her to senior producer. As excited as she is, she informs him that she will still interview for DC because it is what she wants. Jim replies with a lovely confession. That he doesn’t care how many states away it is, this is something more. Maggie agrees. They agree to travel arrangements that would suggest a real effort to make a long distance relationship work.
Maggie: Have you been in many long distance relationships?
Maggie: Did any of them work?
Maggie: Why is this going to be different?
Jim: I wasn’t in love with them.
Sloan is clearly having a hard time processing Charlie’s death. Don walks towards her and picks up a large manila envelope and says, “Nancy wanted me to give you something.” Don gave Sloan the bow tie that Nancy gave to Don.
Mack is pushing back slightly on the promotion to News Director. Citing that it’s only the articles uncovering Pruitt for being gender biased that he would give a woman such a promotion. Will’s point is why does it matter? She’ll get to do the job.
The remainder of the episode is a cleverly shot slow crawl of each of the major contributors to the show. From Will to Mack, Jim, Don, Maggie, Sloan, Neal, the graphics guys, etc. It is slow and lacking any audio polish. This is these people doing the job they were all brought along to do. Journalism was supposed to be a calling. These men and women are simply answering the call. And there is a swelling of pride that comes with the privilege to do just that. Close up of Will at the News Night desk just as the lights come up. Will looks directly in the camera and says…”Good evening.”
. . .
“You know what kiddo, in the old days. About ten minutes ago, we did the news well. You know how? We just decided to.” -Charlie Skinner
Tonight is the penultimate episode of The Newsroom series. While that is a little sad, it should be a very satisfying episode. Thinking back on my experience with Sorkin projects, I do however, worry that something major and not necessarily good is going to happen tonight. I expect more chaos than closure. Closure comes the next week. For now, we’ll have to settle for being unsettled.
We begin to the unnerving sounds that you’d expect with a jail, and a corrections officer trying to brace Will for the events that will follow. Something tells me his efforts aren’t necessary. After the transition to ’52 days later’, we discover Will has a cellmate. Ironically, some of you may notice him from our coverage of Gracepoint. The cellmate is Kevin Rankin who plays Reverend Paul Coates on Gracepoint.
All Will wants to do is read his book in silence. After all, if the FBI is banking on Will crack under the pressure they have dramatically misread their mark. The cellmate is fishing. Ultimately reveals that he is on his third strike for domestic battery. One thing lead to another. Seems like the FBI are not the only one who apparently misread their mark.
Cellmate: You tell me the source, then I’ll tell it to them on the condition they let us both go.
Will: It’s a hell of a plan.
Cellmate: Or I could just shake the name out of you.
Will: Stand up. I want you to see that I have four inches on you and you’re giving up thirty pounds. I’m not your wife. Raise your hands above your hips and I’ll knock you f— into next week.
Mack and Don meet with Charlie to view the new ACN promo. It is crisp and inviting. And is a complete and utter slap in the face to any journalist. Especially the ones set on a ‘mission to civilize’. Mack is visibly repulsed by the spot. Don is more confused. The spot ends with the hashtag, “#uracn”. To which Don claims, “looks like urine”. Charlie who appears to have little to no fight in him at the moment strongly encourages them both to just move on. Don sticks around to talk to Charlie. It appears that Pruitt wants Don to get the victim and the accused of a college sexual assault case on set at the same time. This is six different ways of stupid. Not only are they suggesting anyone with a smart phone can be a journalist, now we are introducing Jerry Springer rules into the newsroom. And Charlie seems content to let is slide.
Gary Cooper gives Mack the rundown of unimpressive developing stories. Mack is unimpressed, even with the Kanye and Kim’s kid is name “North West” joke. She does do a double take on the story about a woman who shot herself in the mouth on the steps of the Department of Justice. That woman was the source. Neal’s source and the reason Will is still sitting in jail. Mack runs straight to Rebecca’s office to explain what she knows. Rebecca begins to pick a direction, but instead declares something very near to everyone involved.
Rebecca: You’re husband’s getting out of jail today.
The addition of new, and I have to assume, Pruitt hires patrolling the twitter-verse has become a problem. Erin Andrews was swarmed by paparazzi on the other side of the country because ACN now has an app the staff are calling the ‘stalker app’. Sloan is past the point of apathy. Which means Don is past the point of apathy on her behalf. There is now a ‘ACN Digital’ which is worrisome on its own. What follows is a typical butting of heads. Don wants them to take down the app, they say take it up with Pruitt. Which is exactly the moment Sloan switches gears. Sloan is a very attractive character in many ways. One thing I’ve learned from watching this character over almost 3 full seasons is that when she gets quiet bad things are on the horizon. She’s offered to have the ACN Digital guy on the show to discuss his app.
Jim and Maggie have been sent to Russia. Considering our relative timeline, the hints to an NSA story, and Jim and Maggie walking through a Russian airport, one must deduce that this is where they break out the Edward Snowden storyline. Shortly after discovering the pertinent news outlets present at the gate, Jim feels more than confident that this is the flight that will take Snowden from Russian to Cuba. The problem is, they are not in the system as having a ticket for this sold out flight.
Will receives two visitors. One is Rebecca and the other is Lasenthaul. With the idea that the woman who shot herself is the source there is no one to protect. All Will has to do is confirm that the dead woman is the source. The FBI has enough circumstantial evidence retrieved from her laptop to be satisfied. This became more about the principle than the information a long time ago. No deal.
Brace yourself for this. The weird keeps getting weirder. Charlie Skinner comes to Mack’s office to inform her that she needs to make room for Lady Gaga’s manager to discuss her tweet about overturning the Defense Of Marriage Act (DOMA). I’m at a loss. There is something building with Charlie and I doubt its triumphant in nature.
In Don’s pursuit of a way out of the on campus sexual assault story, he travels to Princeton to find the victim. Which he does. They have a short and very Sorkin-like fast-moving discussion. Don gives all the telegraphed indications that if she were to do the interview, with the accused in the same room, it would be hugely beneficial to his standing with his job. Then he tells her he’s there not to do the pre interview, but to beg her not to do it at all.
I have made no attempts to disguise my feelings about any storyline that involves Maggie and Jim romantically. However, I would be remiss if not completely in the clouds if I told you that this wasn’t a Josh Lyman/Donna Moss situation. That’s a West Wing reference for those of you new to the Sorkin world. I really love the evolution Maggie has gone through from the African trip until now. All of that said, we just witnessed the commitment to the ‘u-turn’. Josh and Donna in the hotel on Santos election day for the West Wingers keeping score. Maggie strongly suggested that Jim call Hallie just to hear her voice halfway around the world. Jim made the decision, without saying so, to end his pursuits of Hallie and accept that Maggie has been the one all along. To my dismay.
Don has made every attempt to convince Mary (the rape victim) to not do the interview. Both sides, to me, seem perfectly justified. Don’s angle is that nothing good can come of it. As he says, “it will be covered like sports. Teams will be formed”. There is a reason that reputable news sources rarely if ever put victim and accused on at the same time. On her end, if her story can save even one future victim, it’s worth doing. Don was siding a little too heavy on the side of, ‘eventually an innocent person will fall in the name of revenge’ angle. But they both have a valid argument.
Edward Snowden is not on the flight. However, the bigger story to us-the viewer is the inevitable moment when Maggie brings up Hallie again at that perfect moment when Jim’s willingness to admit and opportunity converge, creating the confession of feelings. The natural next step is new and improved Maggie is overjoyed at this new information and her reaction most closely resembles, ‘took you long enough’. That would be the natural next step. That was not the actual next step. Maggie’s been holding onto the part about Jim not calling from New Hampshire. Dwelling on the past and maybe even going so far as to hold a grudge about it.
Rebecca meets Lasenthaul in a hallway outside an assumed office. Rebecca is going to file a motion that will ultimately get Will released on the grounds of “enough is enough”. To our collective relief, Lasenthaul has no intention of contesting the motion.
Jim, sitting as instructed in the back of the plane content to watch an episode of Star Trek is interrupted by Maggie. She wants him to get his seat back. Always awkward. You can’t un-switch seats with someone, it’s uncomfortable at best. Clearly, Maggie has taken time to weigh all of the important information and this time taken her own advice. “If you like her (him in this case) that shouldn’t stop you”. It was a quote intended for the Hallie situation, but it works here too. She leans in slow as if to say something, then abandons any attempt at words and the lean becomes a kiss.
Sloan’s interview with the father of the Stalker App is going exactly as one might think. Calm, but directed. This guy actually believed he was there to promote the app. When in reality he was there to be Sloan’s punching bag and eventually the face of exactly why citizen journalism is a bad idea.
Sloan: What does ‘x’ equal?
Bree: It would be silly to name an exact dollar amount.
Sloan: You’re paid 55 thousand a year…
Bree: Well that’s private…
Sloan: Sorry, that’s almost twice the national average for a family of four. Do your piles of cash protect you from this interview in which I am intentionally stripping you of your dignity? And by the way, I’ve managed to do it without lying once.
Upon the interview’s conclusion Charlie comes barreling around the corner demanding to know if Sloan was put up to the interview. Mack interjects that it was an intervention. Then Charlie demands to know about the college girl from Don. So, Charlie is not getting any satisfactory answers to his questions. Questions I believe, he is compelled to ask because he has been playing the intermediary attempting to save people’s jobs. Just then Pruitt storms in and demands that Mack and Sloan leave the building immediately. Then he threatens to fire the entire staff. Which may actually be the line of demarcation, to borrow a Sorkin-ism. It appears that Leona Lansing wrote into the contract (either Charlie’s or that sale’s) that no one can fire the staff except Charlie.
Charlie: I’ll be back in a minute.
Sorrow filled last words. Charlie Skinner is Leo McGarry. We’ve known all episode long that there was something building with Charlie and it wasn’t going to be good. I for one, was expecting a blow up of massive proportions that ends with his resignation. This was larger. A heart attack with the eventual passing. This is a very sad moment in the timeline to be sure. However, a part of me sees this as a ‘Coulson moment’. A tragedy that brings the team together.
I have skipped over a scene of monumental importance. Throughout the episode we see Will verbally sparring with his cellmate. Suffice it to say that for the most part, on the surface, this is just another angry guy. A guy that has a history. A guy that takes issue with Will’s station in life. The guy that grew up to be ‘Harvard elite’. Who talks down to normal people. And at one point, Will agrees, “down is where some people are”. Will talked about this man hitting his wife. Not matter of factly, but as the primary reason as to why a person like Will can look down on someone like this. The cellmate identified that Will’s father probably was a drunk. Even when Will demanded the man stand up so he could inform him that Will would knock him out if he so much as raised his hands. I never saw it. Full disclosure, this historian of Sorkin for the fun of it-me, did not see it coming. The brilliant Aaron Sorkin just ‘I see dead people’d me.
For those that did not watch the episode and have come here for a detailed account. There was a moment when the cellmate looked at one of Will’s photos of his Dad and fishing. The cellmate said, “maybe your Dad was just trying to teach you to fish”. I didn’t even get it then. When Will is released from jail, we find him cleaning up his belongings. Including the pictures. He pulls the picture of he and his Dad fishing. The camera focuses to reveal that the man who was the cellmate was actually a manifestation of Will’s father. He was never really there. Brilliant stroke by a genius painter in Sorkin. Very well done.
This leads us into next week. The conclusion to this great story. Sorkin himself has eluded to the masses that fans of the show will be pleased with how it all comes together in the end. I’m still processing how I could be pleased about Charlie Skinner dying, but we’ll put a pin in that one. From where I sit there are only two possibilities. 1) The team bands together and their collective efforts convince Pruitt to sell ACN back to Leona for a minimal loss or 2) They figuratively burn the whole darn thing to the ground. Will and Mack take Will’s sizable net worth and start-up a new cable network. Thus forcing all of us to prey for a spin-off series. I wish I had more insights, but I will be tuning in with incredible anticipation next week like everyone else. So, make sure to check back to NJATVS for more updates and the climactic Series Finale recap of the Newsroom.
Charlie Skinner, one of the best characters in modern dramatic television. He will be missed.
Right out of the gate, the News Night team reacts to Will getting subpoenaed. Rebecca runs him through a quick day-to-day rundown of what will happen next. Will spins it again and Mack rejects his premise. She believes he’s been wrong every step of the way on this. Everyone’s phones go off. There has been a press release and everyone has it. Including Jim’s girlfriend, former social media reporter for ACN. Mack pulls Don aside and tells him to be ready by Wednesday night. It’s the story that has Neal on the run and Will in trouble. That’s the time-table the source gave Mack.
Jim and Hallie attempt to leave the Correspondence Dinner early. Maggie’s date (the ethics teacher) jumps into a social question about a friend of Maggie’s dating someone who just signed on with a gossip rag, not knowing that he’s talking about the woman (Hallie) directly in front of him. This leads to an issue between Jim and Hallie because Jim talked about it with Maggie at work. Hallie takes offense to his disapproval of her new job. She claims she had nothing to do with leaking the story about Will at the Correspondence Dinner. Then comes the admission that she may have told her colleagues what to look for. Ironically, this was not the immediate end of their relationship.
Mack attempts to let Charlie and Will in on her little pow wow with ‘the source’, she opts to meet with Pruitt instead. They walk into the room and it is made very clear that they media circus that is now Will McAvoy at the Correspondence Dinner was all perpetrated by Pruitt. Done as a power move on his part to separate him from the Lansing’s.
Lucas Pruitt then goes ahead and gives his relative mission statement, which I have to believe he’s rehearsed many times. Again, he plans to put the power of reporting in the hands (or phones) of the viewers. Integrating social media, not as an after thought, but as the primary source of information. And that is when he loses Charlie. Charlie sits down and gives a rant of Charlie proportions. I would love to transcribe it for you, but it just wouldn’t do it justice. The last part of it would read:
Lucas: The air up there on that pedestal must be pretty thin because you are delusional sir.
Charlie: If I am, I plan on staying that way. And my network is staying too. We’ve got a problem now, you and me. Have a good evening.
The first hearing of Will McAvoy in front of the grand jury goes exactly the way Rebecca said it would. Lots of yeses and one very critical no.
During a staff meeting, the HR guy enters with a very dumb question that reveals a very clever ulterior motive. He asked Don why he hasn’t accepted his friend request on Instagram. Don writes something on a notepad and hands it to one of the associate producers to take to Mack. Instead its a note for Sloan. Which she immediately interprets as she needs to delete anything of her from his Instagram page.
Just as the associate producer was leaving, Charlie was entering. He badly wants to find another buyer that isn’t named Lucas Pruitt. He presents Sloan with a list of rich people. She resists, but she goes down his list. When she gets to the last name on the list, the light bulb in her head turns on. The wife of a wealthy businessman had shown interest in an article two weeks ago. Sloan hopes to set up a meeting so that she and Charlie can gauge interest, quietly.
There is a snag to get the story run on ACN by Wednesday. One of the contributing sources, they believe is still on the ground. If a national network airs a story of Kundanese Islamic radicals rigging an election to ensure the preferred outcome and the guy is still there, best case scenario is that he dies. Best case.
Jim runs home to have a quick sandwich before heading back to the office, where he finds Hallie working on a piece for work. He avoids anything that might precipitate an argument. She resists as she believes he’s baiting her. Eventually she reveals that the piece is an op-ed about her experience with the ‘plan b’ pill. All seems fine. Then Jim sits down and says, “does your piece start with dear Penthouse?” thus pouring gas on a flame.
Will (with Rebecca) and Lasenthal are compelled to meet with a judge. After hearing what the two lawyers had to say, the judge moved to Will. They are familiar. Will tried cases before this judge long before either of them made it to where they are today. The judge does as was predicted and orders Will to meet with the grand jury again.
The staff is having trouble getting the reporter on the ground out. His youngest doesn’t have a passport. Don all but demanded that Mack tell him why they have to run it on that particular day. It looks like she might tell him. Then she says she’s leaving but will return. They have four hours to make this work. And when she comes back, not to ask where she was.
The meeting with Sloan, Charlie and this ‘Toni’ goes exceedingly well. For Charlie she expresses her desire to keep the news professional relying on integrity. So Charlie’s in. Then the two women have a sidebar conversation about finances and projections. Full disclosure, did not get half of it. When the waitress arrives as asked what they would like, Toni has a great response.
Waitress: Have you decided what you would like.
Toni (slightly under her breath): A news network.
Mack traveled to Langley, Virginia. To meet with the source in the hopes that should would ‘lift the deadline’ of Wednesday night. The source is resistant. Idealistic and downright high and mighty about what’s at the core of this circus. Ultimately Mack is more persuasive. They will run the story. Lift the deadline or she will quit her job at ACN and walk to the FBI personally and give them her name. The source is less than polite with her response. There absolutely has to be something bigger at play. The source is guarded about her identity. But she also gets almost emotional charged when talking about the ideology of the transgressions. Revenge? Helping a loved one? Something else has been there beyond doing what she thinks is right.
Will meet with Mr. Lasenthal and the grand jury. When asked if he will comply with the court order to reveal his source, as predicted, Will does not.
Hallie has posted a new article. This time a personal introspective on her relationship with a man who loves her but doesn’t like her (i.e. Jim). She doesn’t use his name. She instead refers to him as ‘Tim’. This is discovered while Maggie and Jack are on a date. She defends Hallie while Jack defends Jim. This goes further than it should, but in the end, Jack informs Maggie that she’s into Jim and defends Hallie to cover it. It would also be a good idea for them to talk about how that makes Jack feel. Knowing any man not named Jim Harper will be playing for second place.
Hallie shows up at ACN to ask why Jim hasn’t returned her calls and texts. Jim doesn’t say much. Then suggests she leave that room as there more than 20,000 classified documents there. They head to the rooftop balcony. The fight ensues. At every turn Hallie throws out a cliché about the ‘digital revolution’ or ‘fear of technology’. After a while it becomes clear that she is trying to make excuses for the work she’s doing. Jim’s real only problem is that it is reality TV in word form. It does appear the breakup is official. Thank goodness.
Somehow the reporter and his family are safely out of the country, thus giving ACN a little clearance to run the story. Then Mack is asked to meet with Reese. Reese informs her that they can’t run the story at all. Pruitt is going to sign the papers to buy ACN tonight. They’ve been informed that if they run the story, the Justice Department will enforce ‘crippling’ fines. Mack is indignant about this. With the source, Neal and Will all hung out to dry the very least they should be certain of is that they are doing the story. Then Reese has a moment that is very un-Reese like.
Reese: The fight with the grand jury isn’t over. They still want his source.
Mack: I know.
Reese: Since the day you got here, Will’s been having a battle with himself. Is he a rogue journalist or just good on TV? You ever think he may be doing this for you? Because I don’t think there’s not a chance he’s going to jail.
Mack: I’ve got his ring on my finger, he’s not doing this to win my approval…
Reese: Then it would be the first thing I’ve seen him do that wasn’t.
Mack tells the staff and tries to hide in her office. Don follows her in. Suggests that they proactively try to leverage not doing the story to get everyone off the hook. Mack suggests they find a responsible reporter who needs a break. One must assume to pass the story off to someone else to run. Don gives her a name then leaves the office. Sloan is there to offer support which involves a hug. A hug that the HR guy witnessed. Not important because back in the first couple episodes, Sloan sent a letter to the HR department citing that they are a couple to avoid any impropriety for what may appear to be insider trading from Don’s purchase of Chipotle shares.
Don gets almost uncomfortably close and fires three very specific things at the HR guy. 1) Sloan would choose her job over Don in a heartbeat 2) Don really likes her and they make it work and 3) the HR guy’s company is only going to own this network for another few hours. The HR guy admits that he did it for fun. The life of an HR rep is a boring one. And for the record he hopes it works out and that he’s a fan.
Charlie runs up to Sloan wanting know exactly what is taking so long as Pruitt just entered the building. An hour early. Sloan does a little digging and finds enough bread crumbs to believe they will announce ‘an exciting media acquisition’ tonight at 5. Don is still in the dark and now he knows it. As the swell of excitement overwhelms, Sloan sees something on her Bloomberg terminal. Halifax is trending up. Toni wasn’t meeting with them to buy ACN, she met with them to create negotiating leverage.
Sloan charges into the board room to intercept Charlie but she’s ten seconds too late. Pruitt knew all about it. Being in a position of perceived power, Pruitt has some comedic and condescending words for Charlie. Which Charlie takes the exception to and has to be restrained because let’s not forget, Charlie is a %@#&ing Marine.
At home Will and McKenzie are having dinner, if you can call it that. Mack charges into this inner struggle to figure out what’s what. Then Will again refers to the source as a ‘he’. Mack tells him he can stop calling it a he since she’s met with her on two occasions. There is a long pause and Will says very calmly but sternly, “You cannot repeat what you just said to anyone”.
It’s now Friday and Will sits in a courtroom to show just cause for his refusal to comply with the court order to produce the name. Mr. Lasenthal and Rebecca go back and forth. Then the judge asks Will what he should do. Then we have a lovely response from Will that illustrates his belief in the necessity of the clandestine services and the integrity of a journalist to protect their source. And finally, that no number of days in prison will change that stance. The judge finds him guilty of contempt and orders him to surrender himself to US Marshall’s by 5pm that day.
Once they exit the courtroom, most of the immediate staff is waiting. Up to and including Mack. Who not jokingly, suggests they get married at 3:30 that day. Will hesitates for half a heartbeat. Then when he realizes she’s not joking, he jumps all over it.
We see what appears to be people wheeling in crates. My first assumption was refreshments for a make shift wedding reception. As it turns out the crates are boxes that have all of the 27,000 classified documents being delivered to Don’s responsible reporter lady who currently works for the Associated Press. The staff run around town trying to secure the essentials for a wedding. All to a contemporary rendition of Ave Maria.
The ceremony is as elaborate as humanly possible with only a few hours to plan. At its conclusion, Will and Mack depart together. Down the hall, the US Marshall’s wait. Will and Mack do their goodbyes. Will takes the slow handcuffed walk. With only two episodes remaining, there are a lot of loose ends to tie up. Join us next week to see where this heads.
Gary Cooper comes strolling into work singing a song from the musical “Anything Goes”. Oblivious to what has happened since our last episode. He turns the corner expecting to see a quiet newsroom. Instead he finds more FBI agents than employees.
Gary is met almost immediately by the lead agent. The exchange obscenities. The agent trying flex his authority and Gary flexing his grasp of legality. Eventually, Will jumps in to toe the line between we’re cooperating and don’t say anything.
The power struggle continues. The agents demanding that everyone do exactly as they say, while the staff tries to casually make their lives easier by suggesting the proceedings don’t have to go down this way. Will suggest that they are just doing their jobs. Then Charlie Skinner steps up and does his job. By calling the LA control room and informing them that ACN will be going live in 3 minutes.
Don and Jim head into the control room. Don claims that Charlie just called Domino’s and they need to make it look like they are about to go live even though they are not. Maggie jumps into the control room to get the ball rolling and question how they have never picked up on how to actually run a news broadcast. Meanwhile, Gary comes out strapped to a camera and Charlie asks the lead agent for his first name so they can put it in the banner.
With the fake special report about to not go live in the next 10 seconds, agent Molly tells them to stand down. And for a moment, ACN-1, FBI-0.
Rebecca (the lawyer) with every one of legal consequence on the phone negotiated a relative ‘cease fire’. The FBI and any agencies of authority will stand down until Friday. At such a time as all of the pertinent people will meet at Main Justice to tell the authorities everything they know minus the name of the source in the hopes that the Justice department can connect the dots without the name of the source.
Rebecca (to Charlie): That stunt with the cameras? That was not cool.
Charlie: Neither am I.
Maggie attempts to hand off her EPA report to Jim. Jim is difficult, but in a comedic way. The end of the world as we know according to the EPA in a report that is an inch thick is not exactly riveting television. Jim reluctantly agrees to try to move it up the pecking order. So this feels more like a Jim Harper segment and less like a Maggie Jordan segment. His words.
Meanwhile, Charlie’s assistant informs him that Leona and Reese Lansing are on their way down. Which is odd in that Charlie always goes to them. Leona does not have 4 billion to throw at the twins. And they have exhausted any conventional means to get it. The only way to get it is to ‘spin off ACN’. AWN is the parent company that owns ACN. If they sell ACN they could get enough in the sale to fight off the twins. There is a tech analyst who left Goldman Sachs to start-up his own company. He has the requisite money, but he also has ideas.
The last thing the iconic desk man of a successful news network wants to hear is that new ownership has ‘ideas’. Ideas mean change. Ideas mean lack of control. Considering that the alternative to this guy buying ACN and maybe making some changes is that the twins will dissolve all of AWN including ACN. A lesser of two evils situation. But now we are faced with Will and other being forced to attend the Correspondence Dinner. Normally a hard ticket to get. The problem here is that last year Will ripped the Correspondence Dinner and promised that ACN would never return.
Don has the new HR rep in his office. The scene is about Gary Cooper and the amount of romantic escapades with subordinate employees. The end of the scene is more critical. The HR rep is probing Don over his alleged relationship with Sloan Sabbath. Denying everything Don appears calm. The rep leaves headed for Sloan’s office. Don taking his time, wipes his mouth with a napkin, calmly stands up, then frantically races to Sloan’s office just to say, “we’re not dating”. Which Sloan replies with her monotone, “okay”.
Mack and Molly met in secret in a women’s sauna. This allows Molly to give Mack just enough information to help her make the right decision concerning her people. After work with the seized hard drives, the FBI is compelled to believe that they can tie Neal to an attempt at more documents. Molly strongly suggests that Mack do whatever she must to get Neal to come in. Mack then meets with Don and Jim. She asks them to get Neal a message to come in however they can.
Maggie’s EPA story and interview for Will. As Maggie predicted it was a story about the end of the world. More specifically, a child has already been born that will die at some point in its life due to the planet failing. This was literally a laugh out loud situation. As I’m watching this and hearing this dire end of the world narrative, the reactions around the room make it very funny. Almost as if the people not in the interview look around every few seconds and say, “did he really just say that?”
Will, Mack, Charlie and Rebecca sit in a conference room at Main Justice. The Assistant District Attorney for National Security enters the room. He is brash and forceful. He takes shots at everyone at the table to display the idea that he is in control. Anything short of giving up the source will not be good enough. Then he claims that Will is the one who orchestrated all of this. That is the point where Will has a moment that only Will can deliver. Transcribing it would be great, but it would lose its gravitas. Suffice it to say that Will said only what he needed to a that the ADA for National Security bungled this whole situation and now Will can’t help him anymore.
The entire staff is in the White House for the Correspondence Dinner. Up to and including the new HR rep who really believes he will catch Don and Sloan as an item. Charlie wants to meet with the staff before meeting their new ‘option’. Except he just walked through the door. Lucas Pruitt (played by B.J. Novak of the Office and Mindy Project fame) may put a halt to that idea. He is abrasive to say the least. He wants to turn ACN into a large family of networks that get their news from crowd sourcing. He’s a quirky rich guy who thinks he’s buying a new toy.
Outside a woman walks up and sits down next to Mack. She is the source. Not only that, but she also is applying her own pressure for Mack to run the story within the next 96 hours or she will post the story herself.
The staff has gathered in a room where Will McAvoy is graciously taking his picture with whomever happens to be at the party who wants to. It’s Will gladly radiating his own fame. Mack walks in like she’s seen a ghost. Charlie picks up on it. The kid at the front of the line finally gets Will’s attention by flashing a folded piece of paper. Will empties the room of ‘fans’. The kid has a subpoena for Will to appear before a grand jury.
Will (looks to Mack and Charlie): You think it’s possible I’m not as big a TV star as I thought?
Last week, in Newsroom fashion, we sat through a very compelling season premiere. A return to the form of season 1. By its conclusion, we felt that all so familiar feeling. The sympathy shared by the sense that ACN and News Night were staring into the eyes of a three-headed monster named conflict. Number one was the downward trend of ratings as fallout from Genoa. They are in a steadfast attempt to earn the public’s trust again. Number two was the understanding that while not his intention, Neal very well has committed espionage. And number three was Sloan adding up the breadcrumbs to equal ‘hostile takeover’.
Tonight’s episode begins with Reese on his best behavior (for now) giving his half siblings a tour of the building while both parties involved are fully aware of what is being attempted. The siblings are silver spoon fed rich kids hell-bent on getting the largest nest egg for a couple 25 year olds maybe ever. It’s slightly unclear if there is a motive beyond that. By taking inventory of the tempers in the room, I’d say there might be a hint of resentment or even revenge.
Neal and Will wait in their station meeting room for Rebecca Halladay (the lawyer from the Genoa case played by Marcia Gay Harden) to arrive. In a little less than 3 minutes of simply discussing the beginning of the very basic timeline of events, Halladay is certain that Neil has in fact committed espionage. If they run the story, which seems very much an afterthought in the negative column, they would have to contact BCD. Calling BCD and asking the question will automatically set off the ‘trip wire’. BCD would be inclined to alert the defense department. The Defense department would tip-off the FBI. Then the FBI would descend upon ACN and take Neil away. Neal is still thinking like a journalist. Willing to do the time to report the story. Will does not accept that.
Mack goes to a FBI shooting range with a friend of hers who works for the FBI. The idea is that she could float vague concept by this friend and the friend could tell Mack just how much trouble we’re looking at. Based on the vague version of the story this friend believes jail time for refusing to reveal the source would be in the ballpark of 10 days.
Point of reference. As it has been pointed out, I am arguably the biggest fan of The West Wing maybe on the planet. So when I discovered that John Gallagher Jr (Jim Harper) is the same John Gallagher Jr that played the high school kid who volunteers for the DNC and ends up chauffeuring Toby, Josh and Donna around the state of Iowa in the episode “20 Hours in America”, I thought it was cute. A nice little innocent connection to the West Wing.
As we’ve proceeded, using premises of story lines from the West Wing, actual dialogue exchanges, and even as recently as tonight using actual places (i.e. Equatorial Kundu) it’s beginning to wear thin. I get it, there’s only so much original stuff a person can make. However, it’s starting to be too much. Predictable even. Would it surprise you to know that Mack’s FBI friend is played by Mary McCormick who also played Commander Kate Harper who appeared in 48 episodes of the West Wing?
The following scene is another step in the direction I mentioned the last week of ‘Maggie rebuilding herself’. In the premiere, Maggie was asked to do a job that most thought was above her. She went out and nailed it. Now, she is on a train out of Boston when she recognized someone who works for the EPA babbling about things he should not be saying in a public place. She takes advantage and gets as much of it as she can. She then approaches the man about it. She covers her bases journalistic-ally and legally, but there is something that seems wrong about getting a story this way.
Don and Sloan are getting lunch at a nice restaurant. I’ll save you the time on this one. Consider what you know about Don and Sloan separately, add the Sorkin style dialogue, and it’s on the subject of are we or are we not a couple. There was one detail of note. Don tells Sloan that he bought shares of Chipotle after she said they’d have a good day. Which was before she went on the air to share such news publicly. Which, makes it a basic insider trading thing somehow. More to come on that I’m sure.
Jim returns to the studio to find Hallie at her desk long after she shouldn’t be. Jim can’t read the signs. She takes him into the control room to inform him of this immense mistake she made. Jim’s reaction is pretty great. The impact of this mistake will end with Hallie being let go, to put it nicely.
Jim (reading the tweet): Republicans rejoice as there is finally a national tragedy that doesn’t involve guns.
Back to Don and Sloan, the conversation leaves the area of insider trading and transitions into the realm of ‘are we a couple’? To which Don assumed they were and Sloan has a hard time categorizing what they are, exactly.
Don: Do you consider us a couple?
Sloan: I don’t understand that question.
Don: Yeah you do, because this is exactly how I act in the same situation. I pretend I’m stupid and hearing impaired. Do you consider us a couple?
Sloan: Do you consider us a couple?
Don: I do that too Socrates…
Sloan: We are…
Sloan: OK, let me just say that…Here’s what we are…
Don: Bring it.
Sloan: I love spending time with you.
Don: Ohh huh ooh man. I can’t believe I’m getting Don Keefered.
In the board room, Charlie is trying very diligently to persuade the siblings to be a part of what is happening at AWM and not tear it down when Reese gets a text alert. He hands the phone to Charlie and tells him to take care of it. The ‘it’ in this scenario is Hallie’s tweet making headlines. Thus, we get the sporadically used but always enjoyed Sam Waterston curse fest. By the end of which, Hallie has invited herself into the room and takes her release admirably. At this point I’m keeping a tally of what feel like recycled West Wing bits. Not inspired by or borrowed from, but direct recycling. This is straight out of the “Take Out The Trash Day” episode. They won’t slip these passed me.
Maggie still on the train, has rescinded her attempt to use the EPA employees public phone call as the lead in to an eventual story. The moral ambiguity was enough for her to drop it. At this point in the episode she has tried to explain that she is just not going to run the story. The EPA guy cannot fathom a reporter simply dropping it for moral reasons. In the meantime of which, she and the slightly creepy guy sitting across from her hit it off. He’s a law professor at Fordham who teaches ethics, ironically. Eventually the EPA guy gets it and in turn gives her a report that even the President of the United States has not seen yet and offers an exclusive interview to be conducted on Monday, keeping her ahead of everyone else.
Leona Lansing enters the board room and rips the siblings a new one with a lovely anecdote about the definition of the word literally. Then promptly kicks them out of her board room. The long and short of it is that Leona plans to offer the siblings 1 dollar more per share than Savannah Capital thus giving Leona 100% of the company and the siblings billions of dollars.
Will signals Neal out of the meeting room and into the air studio. After a pleasant but vague bit of small talk that firmly impresses upon Neal the level of respect Will has for him, Will moves on. He suggests that Neal find a place to go to that he can reach without using a credit card. Leave his cell in his apartment. Will is suggesting Neil run at least for a couple of days so that Will can act at the negotiator. And subsequently the only other person on the planet that knows the name of the source.
Rebecca, Mack, Charlie, Don, and Sloan sit in the meeting room having sidebar conversations when there is a knock on the glass. The FBI has arrived. Earlier, Neal called BCD and given them his name. One of the FBI agents is the one from before. Curiously, she made her social relationship with Mack information available to all including her partner. Even more curious is that she intentionally lied in front of everyone by telling some story about not seeing Mack since last Christmas. Even though they saw each other a couple days earlier.
A previous detail I left out because I was not completely sure where it was head deals with Will, Jenna and retrieving take out menus. Will asked Jenna to get some take out menus. Put them on his desk. Then after ‘they’ arrive come back for the menus. Now that the FBI are in the building and before they get into anything of substance, Jenna knocks on the door and asks for the menus. Tuck that away.
The feds begin the search. Retrieving hard drives and searching work stations. The guy looking through Neal’s work station notices that a filing cabinet has been broken open. Earlier, when Neal got up to go to the bathroom (to call BCD and tip-off the FBI) Rebecca insisted that he leave the flash drive to prevent him from doing something stupid. He tosses his filing cabinet key to Will. Every assumption should point to the idea that Neal still has the flash drive.
We see Neal walking into a side alley (small) parking lot at the end of which is a dumpster. He breaks his iPhone thoroughly enough that he could remove some important part of the tech. He then takes out the Chinese takeout menu and opens it up. He lights it on fire, but not before we read what Will wrote in it.
Now boys and girls, I kept a tally. There were 9 recycled West Wing story lines, scenes, or details that stuck out to me like a sore thumb. I don’t begrudge Aaron Sorkin from reusing some successful pieces from previous shows. The issue I have is that they feel almost identical. Equatorial Kundu? Really it seems to me, you could just google a map and pick a different impoverished nation. Firing Hallie, Leona ripping the siblings, etc. Change the names and tweak the dialogue and its the same stuff. I say this knowing full well that Aaron Sorkin would be on my top 5 people in the world to have dinner with and whose brain I’d love to pick. 99% of the viewing audience is not going to catch it, but I thought I’d share it for perspective purposes.
I cannot express how excited I am for this third and final season of The Newsroom. Season two was different to say the least, but there are a series of questions still unanswered. There is also a great deal of drama and conflict about to befall ACN. And all of this needs to be addressed, dealt with, and all tied together into a nice conclusion inside of ten episodes. So, without any further adieu, let’s get into it.
The season begins with the natural next step from the close of season 2. Will and Mack planning their wedding. To be honest I could just watch an hour of just this. Mack asking for straight answers and Will discrediting her concerns with stuff like, “If Charlie’s my best man, can’t he just keep going back and forth walking with bridesmaids?” And on a different level, are we really supposed to believe that the only men Will feels comfortable in his wedding party are the men that work at Newsnight? Will never befriended Tom Brokaw? or Brian Williams? or some average Joe he went to college with? Just a random observation.
Ironically, I just typed the above without finishing the scene. And Brian Williams’ name was mentioned. I’m either ridiculously lucky on that one, or have crossed over out of the Aaron Sorkin fandom and into the unimportant Nostradamus realm.
Less than four minutes into the episode and Mack spots an explosion at the Boston Marathon. Here. We. Go. Immediately Jim starts dividing staff into groups focusing on various agencies (FBI, Homeland, etc). A quick shot of Maggie working out intensely feels like the imagery that suggests she will spend this season rebuilding herself (metaphorically), which is something I’m not terribly concerned with at this point. I sympathize with the character, but I don’t enjoy the character. Back to the story, we all know they are watching the evidence of the Boston Marathon bombing. The beauty of this show is that generally, we know more than the characters. It’s really a wonderful device to play off of. In this case, they have images and no answers to go with the images.
Charlie Skinner: If I learn what happened by watching the news I’m going to lose my fucking mind!
The staff is undermanned in part because Don Keefer is in jury duty. Which creates a wonderful scene Don being Don moment and quite possibly is the best way to get out of jury duty I’ve ever seen. Will tries to inspire confidence in a speech about why they won’t report fast, they’ll report accurate and it fails miserably. In addition, Elliot Hirsch (the other prominent anchor on this show) wants badly to fly to Boston and be their reporter on the ground. He’s from Boston and it only makes sense. They can’t part with Jim or Don, so Jim suggests they send Maggie. If you are unfamiliar with last season, you will not fully grasp the risk of sending Maggie. However, Jim feels she is ready. That this story at this time is specifically suited to her. Will doesn’t feel as strongly. Regardless Maggie and Hirsch are en route to Boston.
Gary Cooper is the first staffer to get confirmation on anything. Two devices detonated near the finish line. FBI and Boston police confirm. Mack gets the control room ready in seconds. In the air studio Will prepares to go live. Don, Sloan, Mack and Charlie join him. Charlie jumps right in. If it was a suicide bomber there will be a body. If not this will go on for a while. A manhunt like we haven’t seen since Dallas in ’63. Then they all go their separate ways.
What follows is a cinematically intriguing montage of Will anchoring what information they do have and Mack controlling the chaos in the control room. Clearly this story is affecting all of the ACN major contributors. Despite popular opinion, Maggie is on her game getting real news confirmation.
Amidst the chaos of the bombing, Neal enters a password to decrypt a sensitive email sent to him directly. I know we alert you with “spoiler alert” but this I’m not willing to go into just yet. Suffice it to say, I know exactly where this story line is going (and I’m sure I’m not alone). It’s a story line I’m not thrilled with because I like the character Neal. And am concerned with what this will mean for him long term.
Sloan finds Reese Lansing in his office avoiding his siblings. Hold on to that one. His two younger siblings are set to become major stock holders in ACN when they turn 25. From what I know and what I can infer, there will probably be a shift in priorities once these two are introduced to a position of influence. That and Sloan is being informed of just how bad their quarter financial projections are.
Mack heads off her basic staff meeting. Everything is typical. Tips that aren’t confirmed. Eyewitnesses who don’t want to go on camera. Everything is typical. Until Mack throws it to Neal. Who is sitting calmly and matter of factually mentions the motivation of the encrypted email.
Mack: Neal, tell us what’s going on with the Nocturnal Nut Brigade.
Neal: Somebody is trying to give me classified government documents.
(Everyone stops everything and freezes)
Neal: Somebody asked for my encryption key.
Mack: That’s not uncommon is it?
Neal: No but then they asked for a higher level of encryption. Less common but not unprecedented. We use a site, cryptoheaven which is for–
Neal: Yeah. And he told me to get an air gapped computer. It’s a computer that’s–
Mack: Never been linked to the internet.
Neal: Yes. There is literally a gap of air between the computer and the rest of the world. Once I do that, he’s going to give me a flash drive.
Mack: How’s he going to get it to you?
Neal: Look, I know you guys think I live in a world of crackpots, and I’ll grant you that there is a troubling normal to crackpot ratio in my field…
Don: How’s he going to get you the flash drive Neal?
Neal: He’s going to tape it to the inside of the tank of a toilet of a public men’s room.
Don: Bulls eye.
I transcribed the previous because through a number of reasons, I have been lead to believe that this will be the defining story line of season 3. I could very well be wrong, but if I’m right, this is major. We’ll call this the “Snowden” story line for the time being. After the meeting breaks, with most of the staff thinking this is another Twitter Troll gone crazy, Neal walks back to his desk looking dejected. Then Will pulls out his wallet, calls Neal over and tells him to buy an ‘air gapped computer’ as he extends a credit card.
Sloan has been working on an angle that some financial group is about to buy another. She has no concrete evidence, but is working to solve the ‘puzzle’. In typical Sloan fashion the financial story takes priority in her own head. This feels like something is going to get muffed down the line.
CNN had to retract their previously reported story that they had arrested a suspect. Giving a little breathing room to why ACN hasn’t reported the same as of yet. Charlie and Will tag team a quick speech about if anyone should empathize with getting knocked down by misreporting it’s ACN. Then he and Will share a subtle behind the back hi five for dodging a bullet.
Neal ventures out to the restaurant that is to be the drop for the flash drive. There’s a little speed bump, but Neal gets in. And as predicted, the flash drive is there. In the tank of the toilet. Back at ACN, Neal opens the brand new ‘air gapped’ computer and inserts the flash drive. Anyone who’s bought a new laptop knows there are some realism issues with him reading the flash drive 10 seconds after taking the computer out of the box, but I digress. Immediately, the flash drive spits out what looks like 40-50 documents. The range of topics are vast.
Elliot has unknowingly eaten walnuts, which he is seriously allergic to. His prevailing wisdom is that while his face blows up like a balloon, Maggie needs to go on camera and report the story. Maggie puts on the clothes found in Mack’s go bag. She gets ready and looks incredibly nervous. To my significant surprise, Maggie was as close to flawless as one can expect their first time on camera. And a wave of pride swept the ACN studio.
Reese invites Will and Charlie to an office balcony where he is drinking a beer and enjoying the nice night. This is where Reese says he’s proud of the job they’ve done this week as an ice breaker before he and Charlie relay the information of just how far in the ratings News Night has fallen. Reese explains that he wants Will to do the news and do it well, but they can’t do the news if the station doesn’t make money. This is where Will’s personality brings upon our first real shocker of the season.
Will: Well… … …I think it’s time for me to quit.
Neal makes his way out to the terrace and begins to tell Will and Charlie (and Reese who is close enough to hear) that he is in possession of a little over 27,000 stolen government documents. Half of which are classified.
Reese: Yeah…I’m just going to jump off this railing.
Neil tells the story of exactly how he came to be in possession of these documents. Three times. On the third time, Will hears a new detail that Neal neglected to mention. By asking for a couple documents to pass along to his bosses, he in fact is an accomplice to commit espionage.
Throughout this entire episode, I have hesitated on the Sloan Sabbath story line because it feels slow developing. Like her digging and Reese’s concern over the numbers is something that will take time to come to a head. I was right that her digging in the numbers would unearth something. I was wrong about the time table.
Sloan: What is everyone doing out he–Reese!
Reese: We’re kind of in the middle of–
Sloan: When’s their birthday? The twins?
Reese: Why don’t we meet in my office?
Sloan: The Twins! When is their birthday?
Reese: The party’s…
Sloan: Not the party. Their actual birthday. When do they turn 25?
Reese: I honestly don’t…sometime next week. The 25th or 26th.
Sloan: Get your mother on the phone. She has to call the board to an emergency session. Right now. Tonight.
Reese: What are you talking about?
Sloan: You went to Wharton Reese. Wake the fuck up. You’re in the middle of a hostile takeover.
Sloan: Somebody is trying to buy this company.
Just then Jim walks out with the newest development that they have one of the suspects, but he’s hiding in a boat in someone’s back yard. Then we get our Will McAvoy eruption of the episode. You may have seen this in our preview article or even on the promos aired by HBO. The culmination of which is “there’s a guy in the back of a boat in someone’s back yard. I’d like confirmation on that before I say it on the news”.
Just like that ladies and gentleman, the stage is set. Set but with inevitably more conflict and drama to come. Neil needs a lawyer because he’s in a lot of trouble. Two other financial institutions are vying to buyout ACN, presumably so that the ‘twins’ can profit off their trust fund quick enough so they don’t actually have to work. News Night is at the bottom of the relevant news shows and will need to fight their way out to stave of television death. And at the very least there is a Will McAvoy and MacKenzie McHale wedding to plan. Wrap your noodle around that, and make sure to join us again at notjustanothertvsite.com following the conclusion of each Newsroom episode. As well as all of the other top notch high quality shows we’re covering for you. Only at NJATVS.
As NJATVS’ residential Aaron Sorkin enthusiast and unapologetic fanboy, it is my duty and privilege to cover and in this case preview “Newsroom Season 3”. Before you consider the theory that I’m just some windbag critic riding the coat tails of Sorkin’s success as of late with Newsroom, Moneyball, and Social Network, consider the following. I have seen 8900 West Wing episodes (22 x 7 x 58 times). I’ve seen A Few Good Men more times than I should admit. I even came very close to paying for a copy of the stage play on principle. Sports Night is easily the best sitcom involving the sports world to date. And I will debate anyone willing to do so that Studio 60: Live on the Sunset Strip is the best comedic series prematurely ended of all time.
The first and most important detail of which is to inform those not already in the loop that season 3 will indeed be the final season. I know, take a moment to reflect and compose yourself. The first season, like most Sorkin projects, adjusted the bar. Reassessed how we define good television. That may sound lofty, but if you really watch season 1 with open, objective eyes you’ll see just how good it was. Sorkin is a master of characters and it shows throughout that season. We don’t have the time for me to break down each element of season 1 that made it so intensely good. However, rest assured that when the series has concluded and I have time to go back through and break it down properly, I will. If for no other reason than for me to properly place it in its rightful place in television history.
Not all is rosy. I would love to tell you that Season 2 was every bit as good as Season 1. I’d love to be able to say that. A couple of things to bring up first. Will and Mackenzie’s relationship arrives at a crescendo that is satisfying to any viewer by the conclusion of season 2. Jim, Don, Neal and Sloan all go through a series of ups and downs. Jim’s feel more pronounced, but those four do experience a great deal in season 2. One of those has yet to see the depth of his or her journey, but that we’ll save for the actual preview portion. Charlie is great and continues to be maybe my favorite character that is not considered part of the ‘essential’ cast. I would argue that Charlie is indeed essential. Even guys like Gary Cooper (a videographer, not the cowboy) and Reese Lansing made real contributions.
The problem one discovers with season 2 is the departure from the previously held blueprint. Look, it’s not my place to say right, wrong or otherwise. Here’s my take though. The series debuted in 2012. The news stories they would chase because a shade under two years before that. Now the show runners get to pick and choose which stories to chase. The fact that they could pick and choose and didn’t follow a real-time projection was both good and eventually problematic. The problem is that eventually the Newsroom stories were going to catch up to the real life stories. Correct or not, it felt like Season 2 was an attempt to buy time for more desirable story lines later. Instead of following the original blueprint, Season 2 was a complete departure. We were taken on a ride that focused as much if not more on one internal story as opposed to a series of news stories.
Season 2 was not explicitly bad. Let me be clear. I would still put Newsroom Season 2 up against 90% of the television on that year. It’s Newsroom, it’s Aaron Sorkin, it’s HBO. It was going to be good no matter what. There were significant high pressure, high emotional big time moments in Season 2. It was just a different ride. Season 2 was bigger, even though I believe Season 1 was better. For anyone who has not seen Newsroom yet (what’s wrong with you first off), if you’re waiting for the conclusion of the series in order to binge watch it, I’m not going to stop you. For clarity sake, assume that Season 2 is every bit deserving of the accolades, just know that it feels different.
If you are on the fence for some indescribable reason, there are two scenes in Season 1 that should sell. The first one is the opening scene of the series. Will McAvoy is speaking on a panel at a college. It’s a long scene and worth every second you invest in it. This clip can be found easily on YouTube. The other is a scene from the Gabby Gifford’s episode where Will refuses to announce her dead just because all of the other news outlets are. Remember, they don’t do good television, they do the news.
Season 3 is a bit of an enigma. On one hand you have Season 1, measured, steady, and running off a blueprint. Chasing news stories from the perspective of what that would look like from the people doing the chasing. Then Season 2 is a completely different approach. Whether to buy time or just adding drama, we may never know.
The question is, which method will Season 3 follow? With a gun to my head, I’m guessing somewhere between the two versions. Clearly, it seems, we are headed back to an episodic rundown that will include real, actual news stories. The first of which may be the Boston Marathon bombing. Which would mark the first Newsroom response to an act of terror. We saw what happened the night ‘we got Bin Laden’, but we have never seen the team’s reaction in real-time when an act of terror is executed in the moment.
Another major development, the development that I believe will take the show out of the Season 1 model and more into the Season 2 model is the Edward Snowden story line (whether that is the actual story or just a parallel, we’ll have to wait and see). There is a story that deals with a person leaking a massive amount of national secrets. When that happens it will create a convergence of two different while somewhat related entities. On one side you have the leak which is very much newsworthy and the idea that Neal aided in the story coming forward by way of social media. In the Season 3 promo released by HBO, Neal very clearly states, “social media is going to solve this crime”. On the administrative side, Will, Mack and Charlie are all fighting to keep the network from falling into the control of those more interested in social media numbers than that of journalistic integrity.
While the above story lines may seem intriguing enough, the bigger picture is…well the bigger picture. Season 3 will come down to the team’s (Will, Mack, Charlie, etc) ability to not only stave off attacks against their ideals. News doesn’t have to be entertaining to be news. An informed electorate. And everything they stand for. A news show responsibly delivering the news whether its trending on twitter or not. Defending that ideal will be paramount. In addition to that, amidst the pressures to compete in social media, the social media guy (Neal) will be facing some real world trouble. If the leaks were aided in any way, that person could be tried as an accomplice to espionage. All indications are that the one that may have unintentionally committed treason is Neal. And the larger theme that will rule the entire season seems to be the integrity of a news outlet protecting it’s source at all costs.
Will McAvoy: If you have our back, then we’re not going to let you get shot in yours.
There is no question that Season 3 has been written with the series coming to a close in mind. It is my opinion, that Sorkin and the people at HBO must have looked at both seasons and created a dynamic that takes the best of both to create as final season that will not only be satisfying, but exceptional. Sorkin has a beautiful knack of building the moment, the line, the story in such a way that it’s conclusion is ideal. That is when he is given the opportunity to write to a close. This may only be a 3 season run, but I am holding out hope that in three seasons we will feel like we’ve seen every bit of the story. Beginning, middle, and end.
Do yourselves a favor. Set your DVR now. For my money, anything Aaron Sorkin is involved with is great. In some cases we will say “check out ____________, it might prove worth your time”. The worst Newsroom episode made is still without question, worth your time. Set your DVR. Schedule your life around Newsroom. And make sure to check back to NJATVS every Sunday going forward as we will no doubt be on top of this show until we reach its conclusion. And then we’ll probably still write about it in a future retrospective piece.